Metal Siding vs Engineered Wood Siding

When considering engineered wood siding vs metal siding, which is the right choice for your home? Engineered wood is a newer material composed of wood fibers held together by a resin binder. Like steel siding, it can be manufactured in many styles to look like real wood.

When comparing metal siding to wood siding, consider each material’s ability to control moisture and the amount of maintenance required.

The engineered wood siding comparison chart below illustrates the differences between metal siding and engineered wood siding. One of those differences is the superior protection steel offers against water and fire. After you review your options, we’re here to answer any questions.
 

Feature	EDCO Metal Siding	Engineered Wood Siding
Moisture	Does not absorb water Will not swell, decompose or develop mold over time	Susceptible to rotting If water seeps in, the material can warp and buckle If not installed properly, moisture issues can be expected
Appearance	Realistic wood grain look	Mimics a cedar or smooth texture
Warranty	Lifetime non-prorated limited warranty that is transferrable Includes material and labor	50-year transferable limited warranty when installed properly 5-year, 100% labor and replacement warranty
Fire Resistance	Not susceptible to deformation from exposure to heat sources Non-combustible	Manufactured with wood strands which provide very little protection from high-heat including fires
Installation	Little to no caulking required Overlapping of siding panels allows for expansion and contraction due to temperature changes No nailheads are exposed	Joints need to be caulked or have clips added which accentuate the gaps and can fade at a different rate Contractors need to prep and paint every edge of every piece that is cut Nails can be overdriven, causing exposure to moisture
Sustainability	Manufactured with at least 25% recycled steel 100% recyclable	Manufactured with primarily wood strands, engineered wood is considered a renewable source
Weight	Approx. 100 lbs per 100 sq. feet	Approx. 150-200 lbs per 100 sq. feet
Durability	Easily acclimates to any weather condition and will not chip, crack or peel	Over time, it becomes less resistant to impact It can flake and crack. In addition, it can split as product expands or contracts with climate changes
Hail and Fade Protection	35-year fade warranty 50-year hail protection	Does not cover hail greater than 1.75” in diameter
Maintenance	Little to no maintenance required	Requires periodic painting, especially in areas with extended exposure to sunlight

Durability and Maintenance

EDCO metal siding excels in extreme weather, resisting chips, cracks, and peels with little to no maintenance. Engineered wood requires periodic painting and can be prone to flaking, cracking, and splitting due to climate-induced expansion and contraction.

Aesthetic and Installation Considerations

Both siding options offer a realistic wood grain appearance. Metal siding installation is straightforward, requiring minimal caulking and hiding nailheads for a cleaner look. Engineered wood, however, needs additional steps like caulking joints and painting every cut edge to prevent moisture ingress and ensure a uniform appearance.

Environmental Impact and Cost Efficiency

While engineered wood uses renewable wood strands, EDCO metal siding stands out for its sustainability. It is made from at least 25% recycled steel and is 100% recyclable. Considering longevity and minimal maintenance, metal siding might offer a more cost-efficient solution in the long run despite its potentially higher initial cost.

Consistency with Metal Roofing

Combining metal siding with metal roofing creates a harmonious and attractive exterior for your home. Choosing EDCO metal siding and extending the use of metal to your roof enhances the overall resilience and eco-friendliness of your home's exterior, offering consistent protection against harsh weather conditions. This pairing provides a cohesive appearance and maximizes the low-maintenance and long-lasting advantages of metal. Metal roofing comes in various colors and finishes, allowing for seamless integration with the rest of your home's exterior. This ensures your home stands out for its sophisticated style and durability, making it an intelligent investment for homeowners seeking a beautiful, long-lasting exterior solution.

Choosing the Right Siding for Your Home

When deciding between EDCO metal siding and engineered wood siding, it's essential to consider your priorities, such as the sustainability and durability of metal or the renewable quality of engineered wood. Each material presents benefits and drawbacks, making it essential to evaluate them based on your specific needs and preferences. Notably, EDCO's metal siding requires minimal maintenance, while engineered wood siding needs periodic painting, especially in areas with prolonged exposure to sunlight. The engineered wood siding comparison chart on this page shows that steel siding offers enhanced protection against water and fire, underscoring the importance of considering each material's capacity for moisture control and maintenance requirements. If you have any questions or require additional guidance, our team is ready to assist you in choosing the most suitable siding option for your home.